Innovative Legal Solutions

Don't go down with somebody else's Sinking Ship!

In an article published on 30 November 2011 (http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/money/6058202/Warning-of-more-collapses-as-banks-lose-patience), an Ernst & Young insolvency practitioner warned that a lot more businesses are “likely to go under next year” as banks lose patience with borrowers who continue to struggle as a result of the current economic downturn.  

The prediction is based on a view that banks are under pressure to “move things on” in situations where they have previously been more patient and giving a greater opportunity for struggling businesses to recover.

The recent abolition of gift duty also creates some new issues and risks.  Because assets can more readily be shifted into trusts or to other entities at short notice, it is more difficult to know whether the person/entity you are dealing with has, or will continue to have, any assets of note should you end up having a claim against them. 

As a result, even if your own business has no problem with its bank and is not presently struggling, it may be prudent to plan for a greater level of cashflow/debtor/creditor issues next year.   Some of the preparatory steps that could be taken to reduce the risk of stress to your business include:

  • Reviewing your terms of trade or supply contracts, to:
  • o Ensure you can suspend/terminate work when there are signs you won’t be paid,            
    o Give the ability to charge default interest and take other recovery steps in the event of non-payment,
    o Allow you to register a security interest against the borrower (and any guarantor), potentially putting you ahead of any other unsecured creditors;
  • Doing PPSR searches to establish what other securities (and thereby, debts) are already in place with parties you deal with;
  • Ensuring that you actually register security interests on PPSR before handing over any goods, and put a system in place to ensure that all PPSR registrations are regularly checked to ensure contact details are up to date and that the registrations do not expire (they do not last indefinitely and need to be renewed periodically);
  • Getting credit checks of any new customers before providing any credit (you might also want to do them for existing customers where you have a significant exposure);
  • Require statements of financial position or other confirmations from your debtor’s accountant, banker, and/or lawyer to obtain greater certainty around who actually owns the assets you are intending to rely on; 
  • Require personal guarantees from the directors and/or shareholders of any company seeking credit.  Alternatively you may wish to ask for a bank guarantee (as a number of landlords already do).
  • Chasing unpaid accounts as a priority (allowing you to identify solvency issues as early as possible, getting in ahead of the pack but also allowing you to minimise any further exposures to the same party);
  • Talking regularly to your bank when things are going well, and even more so if there is any indication that you will be facing any cashflow or other financial challenges.  The more pro-active you can be, the more the bank is likely to trust you to keep things under control; and
  • Working closely with your accountant and lawyer (as applicable, but often in unison) to ensure that any potential issues are dealt with straight away and also that your business and other assets are structured and held in the most advantageous way (possibly to take advantage of some of the same features of trusts that other people may seek to use to your detriment).

In general, the message is that to a large extent, you can make your own luck.  With potentially tougher times ahead, taking pro-active steps now could save considerable stress/loss later (enabling you to focus on actually growing your business and taking advantage of any opportunities that arise through others being less prepared!). 

News & Events
"Super Ministry" 09/05/2012
John Key has announced that Cabinet has agreed in principle to the merging of the Ministry of Economic Development, the Department of Labour, the... read more more
Proposed Changes to Consumer Credit Law 09/05/2012
The Ministry of Consumer Affairs has released an exposure draft of a bill to amend the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act 2003.  The... read more more
Law change to criminalise breaches of director’s duties! 29/02/2012
Following the recent (and highly publicised) finance company collapses, it has become apparent to many that the law presently lacks appropriate... read more more
Unit title owners – ensure that the Body Corporate holds an Annual General Meeting and attend it! 14/02/2012
The Property Law Section of the New Zealand Law Society has advised that it has come to their attention that some unit title Bodies Corporate are... read more more
Fire in premises. Landlord gave the wrong notice and was done for conversion of the tenant’s goods 19/09/2011
In the case of Birdwood Custodians v New Lynn Compliance Centre, a fire at the leased premises led to the landlord giving a notice... read more more
Request for Facebook Login Information - Employers Going to Far?
REQUEST FOR FACEBOOK LOGIN INFORMATION – EMPLOYERS GOING TO FAR? You may have been astonished to read in the news recently that employers in the... read more more
Charities and the liability of Trustees
A charitable trust begins like any other trust with the trustees liable in their own names as there is no identity different from themselves. To... read more more
PPSR – You need to use it!
It is now over a decade since the Personal Properties Security Register (“PPSR”) came into existence.  Despite it now being a... read more more
Is it worth spending all that money on a LIM?
It sure is!  In the Sunset Terraces Case*1 the Supreme Court suggested that a purchaser is “likely” to be found to have been negligent... read more more
Limiting Trustee Liability
  Trusts are not separate legal entities in their own right.  When trustees enter into contracts they are personally liable for all of... read more more